General education, not personalized tax, legal, or financial advice.
Define the two methods
Both approaches start by keeping required minimum payments current. With the snowball method, extra money targets the smallest balance. With the avalanche method, it targets the highest interest rate. After a debt is repaid, the available payment is redirected to the next target rather than assumed to become spending money. The CFPB describes both methods and their practical tradeoffs. [S30]
Before comparing them, deal with urgent consequences such as a threatened loss of housing or transport and any legal deadlines. A ranking method is not a substitute for addressing an immediate default or disputed debt.
Use a transparent illustration
Consider two hypothetical debts: $600 at 12% APR and $2,000 at 24% APR. The snowball targets the $600 balance first; the avalanche targets the 24% balance first. Suppose an additional $100 can be applied after required minimum payments.
In a simplified one-month model using APR divided by 12, reducing principal by $100 before interest is calculated avoids $1 of interest at 12%, or $2 at 24%. The difference is $1 for that month. These figures are not payoff schedules: they assume the same payment timing, no fees or new borrowing, and no daily-balance complications. Actual statements can use different conventions.
The example shows why rates matter, not how many months a real household will save. A complete projection must include all balances, actual minimum-payment rules, the recurring payment budget and the timing of every payment.
Keep comparisons fair
Use the same total budget in both scenarios. Keep new borrowing, fees, rate changes and payment dates consistent. If a calculator quietly increases one scenario's payment or omits a transfer fee, its result is not a clean comparison of payment order.
Check the first projected statement against a manual calculation and confirm that the final payment is not larger than the remaining amount due. Record rounding rules. Treat the result as conditional on the inputs rather than a guaranteed discharge date.
Choose and monitor
The CFPB notes that clearing small balances can make progress visible, while prioritizing higher rates can reduce costs. Consider both the cost comparison and the routine you are likely to maintain. [S30]
Track actual payments and revise the estimate when terms or income change. If essential bills leave no room beyond minimums, address that constraint first. There is no benefit in selecting an impressive projection that requires money the household does not have.